Twitter 'trolliday' protest against abuse divides opinion

Thumb_alastair-stewart
Thousands will take part in the #twittersilence protest today.
Thousands will take part in the #twittersilence protest today. Photo: Press Association

There is a fascinating debate raging on Twitter over '#twittersilence' - a campaign to keep one's '140 character powder' dry, for 24 hours.

The self-denying ordinance is in protest at the hideous and illegal effluent gushing from the poisonous 'pens' of what are commonly called 'trolls' - often, though not always, anonymous inadequates who target individuals for their beliefs, creeds, sexual preferences and, most pitifully, gender.

Read: Twitter 'trolliday' declared in protest at abuse

It began with Caroline Criado-Perez who had the audacity to suggest a woman, in addition to HM the Queen, should grace the paper currency. She won but at a frightful price.

She was abused, humiliated and threatened in an entirely unacceptable fashion.

Read: Equality campaigner Criado-Perez targeted on Twitter

Then came the impressive Labour MP for Walthamstow, Stella Creasy, who was threatened with rape and other assaults. She has reported some of her 'trolls' to some good effect - the Police are now investigating several individuals.

Cc0fdfb01877b5e2be1eb7b6c5b63e5f_normal

pleased the police have made an arrest - hopefully the start of holding all those who make threats to account #vawg #takebacktwitter

A number of high-profile 'tweeps' - Caitlin Moran, Francis Barber, Kirstie Allsop and Matthew d'Ancona have joined this 24 hour protest.

Photo_on_2010-07-08_at_17.12_normal

I'm going to be off until midnight on Sunday, except for Tweeting the hashtag #twittersilence #trolliday #bepolite

108c907dc3ca489b74ae24db39dfc8af_normal

I've thought about it a great deal, and on balance I reckon #twittersilence is a good idea. I hated being abuse & it cannot be tolerated.

So have I.

The gist of the debate is between those who say this silence is an acquiescence to the very 'trolls' we are objecting to and those of us who think it a reasonable gesture of protest and solidarity.

There are some who see it is a freedom of speech issue but I think they are on an extreme limb.

1345d902a7157b8dcedbfb4f0ea41056_normal

I support everyone taking part in #twittersilence today, & I support everyone who is #shoutingback for the next 24 hours.

Sam_twitter_normal

Ok, not doing it. Total respect for those who are, but, for me, talking back is more powerful than shutting up. #twittersilence

The key to our position is that , for several days now, we have 're-tweeted' the detritus littering on timelines so people can see what is being said to, and about, whom.

It is as eye-opening as it is distasteful. Further, we have urged action which has resulted in police activity and a very public apology from the boss of Twitter UK.

Read: Twitter boss makes personal apology to troll victims

The key to the other side's position, well articulated by the excellent Dan Hodges, is that silence means the trolls have won.

881e9c8bf37ae5b9d4ae42538c9d8787_normal

Responding to people trying to silence you by silencing yourself is bonkers.

Bonnie_greer_photo_normal

“Whoever is able to make you absurd is able to make you unjust.” Voltaire #twittersilence

S3kjsu46fpp1x98zvxi0_normal

The #TwitterSilence that should end is when any of us don’t speak out against bullies & abuse, online or offline.

The purpose of this brief blog is to urge you to look at Twitter and see what has been said and what is being said; it is also to encourage some discourse about social media - a platform I eschewed for a long-time but now see as a useful journalistic tool and an amusing, and informative, means of communication between friends, colleagues and strangers.

In the right hands it is gold-dust; in the wrong hands it is malicious, hurtful and illegal.

Worth pondering.