Three councillors opposed to the closure of Woodlands care home near Distington addressed the adult scrutiny panel and set out seven flaws they believed were in the consultation process which took place early this year.
After three house of deliberation and debate the panel made the decision to support the decision cabinet made last month.
More top news
Film stars including Kelly MacDonald and Jessica Hynes are in the Lake District this evening for the world premiere of Swallows and Amazons
Emma Jesson brings you Sunday night's forecast
It was the 10th visit from the youngsters, who live in the contaminated area near the derelict Chernobyl nuclear power station