Shrewsbury goalkeeper Chris Weale fouled JP McGovern in the area on 68 minutes and Miller put United back on terms.
The game ended 2-2 but there was worse news for Carlisle with winger Matty Robson limping out of the game after only nine minutes with a suspected back problem
More top news
Kerrie brings you Sunday night's forecast for the Border region
Gary Dicker volleyed past Luke McCormick from 25 yards out to give Carlisle United the lead on Saturday
The West Cumbrian school is due to close this summer. The governors say falling pupil numbers mean it is not financially sustainable.