Pro-smoking lobby group Forest has questioned the need for a change to smoking legislation, after South of Scotland MSP Jim Hume proposed plans to ban smoking in cars with children.
"Most smokers are sensible enough to know that lighting up in a car with children is inconsiderate at best and research suggests that only a tiny minority still do it.
"Education has to be better than yet another law that would be very difficult to enforce."
"A ban on smoking in private vehicles would represent a major intrusion into people's private lives. What next, a ban on smoking in the home if children are present?"
“We don’t encourage adults to smoke in cars carrying children but legislation is out of all proportion to the problem.”
More top news
Since a lower drink driving limit came into force, Dumfries and Galloway has seen a bigger reduction than anywhere else in the UK.
Nicola Sturgeon has said the SNP would listen to arguments. Alex Salmond says they have - and are set to vote against military action.
A man from Eastriggs near Annan has been shortlisted for a national award as the "Deafblind Person of the Year."