Helen Ford spoke to Simon Walton, who chairs the Campaign for Borders Rail, and put it to him that just last week an economic think tank described the project as "exceedingly poor value for money."
More top news
Emma brings you Saturday's forecast for the Border region
Paralympian double gold medalist Libby Clegg says "it's not even sunk in yet" as she returns home to Newcastleton.
Police are concerned for the welfare of Ronald Benstead, a missing man from Carlisle.