Helen Ford spoke to Simon Walton, who chairs the Campaign for Borders Rail, and put it to him that just last week an economic think tank described the project as "exceedingly poor value for money."
More top news
Staff have been the victim of online trolling. A petition against the use of animal fat in £5 notes was started by a man from Keswick.
As flooding destroyed homes and businesses in west Cumbria, no one expected the chaos to spread across the region over the coming days.
Looking back on a turbulent year: Paul Brand and guests discuss Brexit, Trump - and hopes for 2017.