Opinion is divided in a Borders town, over an island which has formed naturally in the River Tweed over the last 20 years.
It's been described by some as an eyesore, and there are calls for it to be removed. Other people say it's a part of nature, and to remove it could damage the wildlife.
Jenny Longden reports.
More top news
Sunny spells, showers and rain - it is all in there
Peter MacMahon's blog: Official figures show huge decline in North Sea revenue hit Scotland's finances
Officers from Cumbria Police returned home from the force championships in Wales with a stack of trophies after smashing records.