The Mansfield chief executive told ESPN after the Mansfield v Liverpool game:
"I have enjoyed the day but it feels like it was stolen from us, whether it was deliberate or not. I feel it should be sorted out, we put up a sterling effort and we are proud of ourselves.
"It was not in our favour and we should have had at least a replay. Handballs are obviously de rigueur in this game we play."
More top news
The cigarettes, worth over £7,000, were stashed in biscuit tins.
Nominations are now open for the 2017 ITV Fundraiser of the Year – part of the Daily Mirror Pride of Britain Awards.
A prisoner went on the run after escaping from the exercise yard before carrying out a two-week crime spree.