President of the Black Country Chamber of Commerce, Paul Bennett has told ITV Central shops need to innovate to compete with the internet.
Retail sales did rise over the Christmas period, but only by 1.5%, which is under the rate of inflation.
Mr Bennett says shopping centres need to be a more attractive experience to rival online.
More top news
A traffic warden was issuing parking fines outside a school, but that's not why parents are angry at him...
The father of Jeremiah Regis-Ngaujah was in court to see his son's killer jailed.
Chevaze Sanchez McGregor, who murdered his two-year-old stepson, can be seen shoving family members following an argument.