The Leicester Haymarket Theatre, which closed in 2007, is costing the council £150,000 a year on a lease that has another 60 years to run.
Leicester City Council is now hoping to find a developer by advertising the property online for a price in the region of £500,000.
If the council continues to lease the property, the final cost will total £9m.
The theatre was once considered one of the country's top provincial theatres, attracting stars like Anthony Hopkins and Peter O'Toole.
More top news
Some showers, although many places will stay dry.
Mainly dry tonight. Showery rain spreading in tomorrow.
Team GB swimmer Adam Peaty, from Uttoxeter in Staffordshire, has broken the world record for the 50m breast stroke.