Workmen tackling a leak in the churchyard of St Mary's Church in Hinckley stumbled upon a burial chamber thought to be 100 years old.
The two Severn Trent workers were tackling the leak beneath a footpath in the graveyard.
Mark Kirk, of the digging team, said:
When we struck it the bricks fell away and we saw water in there, it was full to the top. We dropped our pump in and when I looked in there I saw a skull looking back at me.
The church now plans to reseal the chamber and decide whether Leicestershire Police need to be informed.
More top news
Heavy snowfall has caused widespread disruption across the East Midlands, with icy roads and snowy conditions affecting travel services.
Cold with wintry showers and the possibility of further snow in the east.
Weekend weather forecast - more snow to come ?