Blackberry party stabbing trial

Ashley Charles denies murdering Preston telephone executive 37 year old Phillip Sherriff at the corporate event in London

View all 9 updates ›

'This is a tragic case' Judge tells Phillip Sherriff murder trial

"This is a tragic case. Mr Sherriff may have pushed you in a crowded bar and made inoffensive remarks to a girl talking to you.

"You clearly became annoyed at what you perceived was the conduct of Mr Sherriff and lost your temper when he may have pushed against you at the bar."

– Judge Paul Worsley

Charles took a beer bottle from Mr Sherriff's hand and swung it behind him, where it broke, and then plunged it into Mr Sherriff's neck.

"It was a lethal weapon. He was a decent man," the judge added.

He said Charles had done something "which was truly out of character".

"You did not deliberately smash the bottle you used. I am satisfied you did not intend to kill Mr Sherriff and you were immediately remorseful."

– Judge Worsley

Andrew Hall QC, for Charles, said he acted "in a split second of madness".

More on this story