The Taxpayers' Alliance says more coaches should be way forward rather than the HS2 rail link, which would speed up journeys between London and the North.
Matthew Sinclair, Chief Executive of the TaxPayers' Alliance, said:
"As the projected costs have increased dramatically, the already fragile case for HS2 has completely disintegrated.
"There are far cheaper and better ways of substantially increasing capacity much more quickly on the route, not least by reducing the number of first class carriages and lengthening the trains."
More top news
Emma Jesson brings you Saturday's forecast for the North West.
Former Rugby League player Tony Barrow has been diagnosed with an aggressive brain tumour.
Alton Towers rollercoaster crash victim Vicky Balch has posted an 'inspired' first picture since losing her right leg.