Parents had argued that Downhills Primary was now thriving - and that turning it into an academy made no sense.
But, as he refused permission for a judicial review, Mr Justice Kenneth Parker said that it was a rational decision to turn it into an academy, in the light of the school's "egregious" past performance.
He said that it was clear that the Education Secretary "simply had no confidence" that the school would substantially improve if it remained within the control of Haringey Council.
On the other hand, he "believed firmly" that conversion to an academy would substantially improve performance.
More top news
Two police officers helping to guard diplomats have been sacked for sharing pornographic images on their mobile phones.
A 32-year old man from Hampton has been jailed for five years historic sexual assaults in the late 1990s.
A teenager who was mistakenly released from prison after he was arrested on suspicion of attempted murder has been detained by police.