London mayor Boris Johnson said: "At last, justice and the well-being of Mr McKinnon have prevailed.
"I have long supported Gary's right to be tried here in the UK.
"To extradite a man diagnosed with Asperger syndrome to America for trial would have been extraordinarily cruel and inhumane. I applaud the Government's stance.
"If they had approved extradition, they'd have been saying that extradition on any grounds was OK. It's not."
Melanie Riley, of campaign group Friends Extradited, said: "We are relieved and delighted for Gary and his family and his lawyers.
"A brave and correct decision has finally been made by the Home Secretary."
More top news
London mayor Sadiq Khan is "extremely worried" about knife crime as Met Police revealed there was an increase in stabbings in the capital.
Camden police have responded to reports of an unexploded World War Two bomb in Hampstead high Street.
AFC Wimbledon face Plymouth in the League Two play-off final at Wembley, with a place in League One at stake.