The attack on Tottenham supporters happened at Rome's Drunken Ship pub.
Bar co-owner Gabriele Cianella said the attackers had thrown pieces of iron at the windows and were wearing knuckle dusters.
I think this is the first time that something so bad has happened. We have had other incidents like this but this is the worst.
If you throw stones and knuckle dusters I think you want to hurt someone. There was a lot of blood inside on the floor.
Now we also have some blood on the windows. They came here to hurt someone.
More top news
Muhiddin Mire cut the throat of a stranger at an east London tube station "in revenge for the fight against IS", a court heard.
Rory Geoghegan claimed the lack of support he received from the Met shows how frontline officers are being taken for granted.
A registered sex offender who admitted grooming a 14-year-old girl and then sexually assaulting her has been jailed for over four years.