Bob Crow, general secretary of the RMT transport union, said:
"While this report reinforces once again that our railways are nothing more than a multi-billion pound rip-off lining the pockets of a bunch of spivs and speculators, it ducks the real issue and that's the cast-iron case for public ownership.
"You can't have transparency, accountability and value for money while our railways are bust apart and run as a money-making racket for a gang of private operators."
More top news
Labour leader tells May Day rally his party 'stand absolutely against racism in any form'.
Video has emerged of a police car colliding with a cyclist and driving over a bike during a mass bike ride in central London.
Harlesden's James DeGale has successfully defended his IBF super middleweight title against Rogelio Medina.