Bob Crow, general secretary of the RMT transport union, said:
"While this report reinforces once again that our railways are nothing more than a multi-billion pound rip-off lining the pockets of a bunch of spivs and speculators, it ducks the real issue and that's the cast-iron case for public ownership.
"You can't have transparency, accountability and value for money while our railways are bust apart and run as a money-making racket for a gang of private operators."
More top news
West Ham have opened an investigation into a flyer that was allegedly distributed ahead of the game with Chelsea.
Damon Joseph Smith smiled and waved at his mother, who waved back.
Tanguy Marie De Carne, 53, jumped red traffic lights and rode on busy pavements through the City pursued by police