This decision is a humiliation for Jeremy Hunt and raises major questions about his judgment.
Instead of graciously accepting the first court ruling, he has squandered thousands of (pounds of) taxpayers' money trying to protect his own pride and defend the indefensible. He is diminished by this ruling and has let down the NHS.
Today, the Secretary of State must accept this decision, apologise unreservedly to the people of Lewisham and give an unequivocal commitment that their A&E will not now be downgraded.
More top news
Tonight it will be feeling chillier but will be brighter tomorrow.
The clinic has apologised for the human error that resulted in the private health information of HIV patients being leaked.
The multi-millionaire strip-club owner defended his policy of taking 23% of the service charges made by waitresses in his bars.