Mandelson attacks energy plan

Lord Mandelson has warned that Ed Miliband's plan to freeze energy bills risks taking Labour "backwards."

Live updates

Davey compares freeze plan to California blackouts

Ed Davey warned a price fix could result in energy shortages. Credit: PA

Liberal Democrat Energy Secretary Ed Davey warned that a price freeze could result in the lights going out.

"Everyone wants to help with the cost of rising bills, which is why Liberal Democrats have cut income tax by £700 for working people. But Labour's plan is a promise that won't work," he said.

"When they tried to fix prices in California it resulted in an electricity crisis and widespread blackouts. We can't risk the lights going out here too.

"Fixing prices in this way risks blackouts, jeopardises jobs and puts investment in clean, green technology in doubt."

npower: Prize freeze would rule out new investment

npower boss Paul Massara said a prize freeze would have to result in no new investment in power stations. Credit: npower

Paul Massara, npower CEO, said: "It's very easy for politicians to come up with simple-sounding solutions to difficult problems.

"But in reality, there are three main factors that influence prices: fixing inefficient housing stock, the investment required to replace the UK's energy infrastructure and the cost of the buying energy on the global market.

"If the Labour Party can commit to reducing policy costs on household energy bills, stopping the smart meter roll-out, preventing commodity cost increases and accept that there won't be any investment in new power stations and infrastructure, then we could freeze our prices.

"But will this make things better for Britain?"


Price pledge 'encourages suppliers to inflate prices now'

A price comparison website suggested firms would put tariffs up sooner if they thought a price freeze was coming. Credit: PA

Price comparison website said: "This certainly puts the pressure on suppliers to inflate prices between now and the election as they won't be taking any chances on the voting outcome.

"The funny thing is, though, you can already freeze your energy bill with some tariffs until 31st March 2017 which beats Labour's pledge."

CBI: Price freeze 'will deter much-needed investment'

John Cridland, director-general of the pro-business lobby group CBI, said:

Businesses will view the proposals on tax and energy as a setback for Labour's pro-enterprise credentials.

Rising energy bills are tough on families and businesses, but the proposed energy price freeze will deter much-needed investment and is at odds with Labour's pledge to decarbonise the economy and create a million green jobs.

The main reasons that bills are going up is the combination of rising wholesale prices, the cost of policies needed to keep the lights on and the move to a low-carbon economy.

– John Cridland, CBI

Conservatives: Freeze would increase bills by £125

Grant Shapps said Ed Miliband's energy price promise would increase household bills. Credit: PA

Conservative Party chairman Grant Shapps said a price freeze would actually increase household energy bills over the next two decades.

"While we're forcing energy companies to put their customers on their cheapest tariffs, Ed Miliband would introduce an energy policy that would add £125 to the typical household's bill," he said.

The party said a 2030 decarbonisation target supported by Labour would mean a rise of that scale over the next 17 years.


Energy firm: Freeze would cause 'loss-making business'

SSE said Labour should cut energy bills by increased taxation. Credit: PA

Energy firm SSE (formerly Southern Electric and Scottish Hydro Electric) said: "Instead of price freezes which will lead to unsustainable loss-making retail businesses, the Labour Party should put policy costs into general taxation, taking them off energy bills.

"This would wipe £110 off the average person's bill and shift the cost away from those who can't afford to pay and on to those who can."

Cameron attempted lowest-tariff policy last year

David Cameron tried to get the big six energy companies to put customers on their lowest possible tariffs. Credit: PA

In October 2012, David Cameron promised to compel energy firms to put customers on their lowest possible tariffs.

The Prime Minister's Energy Secretary Ed Davey later admitted that while the policy would make energy bills simpler, it would not necessarily make bills cheaper.

The "Big Six" energy companies said the plan would be very difficult to put into action.

Miliband: Energy freeze saves households £120

Gas and electricity prices will be frozen for homes and businesses for 20 months after the 2015 general election if Labour wins power, Ed Miliband announced today.

The Labour leader said the move would save the typical household £120 and an average business £1,800 between May 2015 and January 2017.

But the policy puts him on collision course with the "Big Six" energy companies, which stand to lose an estimated £4.5 billion and have not been consulted on the scheme.

Load more updates Back to top

Latest ITV News reports