Live updates

DWP: 'Bedroom tax' is saving the taxpayer £1 million a day

Our reforms are necessary to restore fairness to the system and make a better use of social housing. Unreformed, the Housing Benefit bill would have grown to £26 billion in 2013/14.We have given councils £345 million since reforms came in last year to support vulnerable groups, especially disabled people.

The removal of the spare room subsidy means we still pay the majority of most claimants' rent. But we are saving the taxpayer £1 million a day which was being paid for extra bedrooms and are freeing up bigger homes for people forced to live in cramped, overcrowded accommodation.

– Department for Work and Pensions spokesma

MPs urge more 'bedroom tax' exemptions

The work and pensions select committee voted down a proposal from Labour MP Sheila Gilmore to call for the policy, officially known as the removal of the spare room subsidy, to be scrapped but it did urge ministers to exempt:

  • anyone whose home has been adapted to help them with their disability
  • any household containing a claimant receiving disability benefits at the higher level
  • carers living with disabled people should be exempt from the benefits cap

It said that it was "particularly unjust" for homeless people to be subjected to the benefits cap, as they have no choice over the temporary accommodation in which they are placed, which may force them over the limit. The committee called for them to be exempted from the cap.

Advertisement

'Bedroom tax' causing 'severe hardship and distress'

Disabled people are suffering "severe financial hardship and distress" as a result of the 'bedroom tax', a cross-party committee of MPs has said.

People stage a demonstration over bedroom tax outside the Liberal Democrat conference in Glasgow in September 2013.
People stage a demonstration over bedroom tax outside the Liberal Democrat conference in Glasgow in September 2013. Credit: David Cheskin/PA Wire

The decision to reduce housing benefit payments from social tenants deemed to have a larger home than they need has hit vulnerable people who were not the intended targets of the reform and have little hope of moving to a smaller property, the House of Commons Work and Pensions Committee found.

Labour: 20,000 tenants wrongly charged 'bedroom tax'

The Labour party is claiming more than 20,000 councils tenants have been wrongly paying the so-called "bedroom tax" because of a Government error.

Labour claims thousands of tenants have been wrongly paying the so-called "bedroom tax." Credit: Press Association

Shadow work and pensions secretary Rachel Reeves says that 194 councils out of 346 who replied to a Freedom of Information request showed that 21,500 people have overpaid.

The coalition says it is working on fixing the loophole which is causing the errors.

Work and Pensions Secretary Iain Duncan Smith challenges Labour's figures, claiming the amount of tenants who have overpaid was likely to be around 5,000.

Read more: What is the government's controversial 'bedroom tax'?

'Bedroom tax' campaigners to consider further action

Lord Dyson, Master of the Rolls, said the legal challenges were to two "of the Government's most controversial measures" relating to state benefits.

The court could only intervene if the measures "were manifestly without reasonable foundation", the judge said.

He ruled that the test was not satisfied and both challenges must fail.

Campaigners outside the Royal Courts of Justice in May 2013 Credit: Lewis Whyld/PA Archive/

Read: Five lose court bid to rule 'bedroom tax' unlawful

Representatives for two of the people with disabilities who lost their bid said they were "extremely disappointed" and "baffled" by the court's findings.

"We are currently considering whether an appeal to the Supreme Court is possible" said Ugo Hayter, from law firm Leigh Day.

Advertisement

Five lose court bid to rule 'bedroom tax' unlawful

Five disabled tenants have lost their bid at the Court of Appeal to have the UK Government's so-called "bedroom tax" declared unlawful.

The changes were introduced last April. People living in social housing who were deemed to have a spare bedroom were asked to downsize or accept a reduction in housing benefit.

Read: What is so-called 'bedroom tax'?

The UK Government argues the changes save money and help deal with a housing shortage Credit: Press Association

Two lone parents have lost their separate Court of Appeal challenge to the legality of the "benefit cap".

Judges rejected claims that the policy violates human rights laws and the common law because of its impact on vulnerable families.

Read: DWP expects 'very few' affected by 'bedroom tax' error

'Spare bedroom subsidy' vs. 'bedroom tax'

In test cases of national importance, today's ruling at the Court of Appeal will decide whether "bedroom tax" regulations, introduced last April, are an "excessive and unfair burden" on people with disabilities, or a lawful and "integral aspect" of the Government's deficit reduction programme.

Backed by the Equality and Human Rights Commission, lawyers for five tenants are arguing that the regulations cannot be allowed to stand.

The Department for Work and Pensions rejects the "bedroom tax" tag and says the reality is a "spare room subsidy" has been removed from social sector tenants.

Read: Court ruling due on legality of 'bedroom tax'

The change in regulations is expected to produce savings of £500 million a year, but opponents say they have had a "devastating" impact on many people and fail to reflect the actual needs of disabled people for extra space.

Court ruling due on legality of 'bedroom tax'

The Court of Appeal will rule today on the legality of the Government's so-called "bedroom tax," which campaigners say unlawfully discriminates against the disabled.

Protesters against the bedroom tax gather outside the Royal Courts of Justice in London.in May 2013. Credit: PA

Judges will also decide in a separate case whether or not the "benefit cap" violates human rights laws and the common law because of its impact on vulnerable families.

Read: What is the government's controversial 'bedroom tax'?

DWP expects 'very few' affected by 'bedroom tax' error

The Department for Work and Pensions said the regulations were now being amended and that it still believed its earlier estimate of the numbers affected by 'bedroom tax' errors was correct.

The Department for Work and Pensions stands by its figures on the number of people wrongly billed over so-called 'bedroom tax'. Credit: Press Association

A spokesman said: "We expect very few people to be affected by this - around 5,000 - and are working with councils to ensure affected claimants are kept informed.

"The removal of the spare room subsidy means we still pay the majority of most claimants' rent, but the taxpayer can no longer afford to pay the £500 million cost of claimants' extra bedrooms."

Read more: What is so called 'bedroom tax'?

Load more updates

Advertisement

Today's top stories