A court has heard how a man found his murdered sister-in-law's body at her home, after going to see if she was alright.
William Kibble gave evidence at the trial of James Allen, who's accused of murdering Julie Davison from Whitby, and Colin Dunford from Middlesbrough.
Throughout the day at Newcastle Crown Court friends and family have described the last moments of Ms Davison's life.
You can see the full report from Dan Ashby below:
More top news
A new look for our political programme from Westminster - Paul Brand and guests consider Theresa May's vision for Brexit.
Dave Jones laid out his vision when he was officially unveiled as the new manager of Hartlepool United
Calm but cloudy - but when will we see some sunshine?