The chairman of Cleveland Police Federation, which represents rank and file officers, said there has to be a completely independent investigation into the way the force handled former officer Wayne Scott.
Currently the police watchdog, the IPCC, is allowing Cleveland officers to look into their own force on the IPCC's behalf.
But after hearing the allegations on ITV Tyne Tees, the federation says only a fully independent investigation would provide credible answers.
More top news
Police have charged a 33-year-old man in connection with an alleged assault in Normanby.
Newcastle manager Rafael Benitez has been charged over comments he made about referee Andre Marriner.
The family of a man who died after a vehicle collision in Newcastle have said he had a “smile as big as his heart".