Many of the UKs largest charities use face-to-face fundraising and it can be extremely effective when it is done well and sensitively by an experienced agency.
Unfortunately, all activity of this kind is being tarred with the word 'chugging - which has become shorthand for aggressive 'in your face' fundraising by people on commission.
I said at the Select Committee hearing that some of the public dont like that sort of fundraising and they see it as disgraceful.
More top news
It comes after the collapse of BHS in 2016 with a £571 million deficit in its pot for 19,000 pension holders.
One newspaper has picked a northern city as Britain's best place to live, due to its ancient beauty and recent modernisation.
A shock to the system