Yellow crime scene tape covered the street in New York's West Village where 25-year-old Mike Jones was stabbed and had his ear cut off in the early hours of Sunday morning.
One local told WNBC News that they had "never seen anything like it", while another described the murder as "horrifying".
More top news
Temperatures up with sunshine and thunderstorms
Real Madrid won another Champions League title, beating a shell-shocked Liverpool side 3-1 in Kiev.
Health Minister Steve Brine called for a possible investigation by the Competition and Markets Authority.