The backlog of 153,000 notifications could potentially have meant that thousands were wrongly allowed to remain in the country, the Chief Inspector of Borders and Immigration said.
The tip-offs were all reviewed by May this year, but Mr Vine said it must be an "ongoing priority" to make sure checks are carried out.
His team examined work at three UKBA offices in Sheffield, Beijing and Delhi.
More top news
Rain across central Britain with longer, intense downpours with thunder in places this evening. A lucky few will stay sunny and dry.
Planning on going to the London Marathon tomorrow? Read our handy guide first!
Labour plans to cap above-inflation rent rises over a three-year period, if they win the General Election.