The BBC Trust found that, although Lord McAlpine denied the allegations when he was contacted by a Channel 4 News journalist before Newsnight was broadcast, the BBC still made no attempt to contact the peer, which it should have done.
Trustees also said that concerns had been raised previously about the credibility of some of Mr Messham's evidence - which was known to members of BBC Wales, but no effort was made to contact them.
The Trustees considered that parts of BBC News not contacting colleagues in the nations and regions when investigating stories on their patch was very poor practice.
More top news
A woman involved in a car crash had to be taken to hospital by helicopter with serious injuries.
Search for missing seven-year-old underway after he was reportedly abandoned in a forest by his parents as "punishment" for throwing rocks.
Shooting of a 400-pound gorilla who grabbed a four-year-old boy after he entered his enclosure sparks public outrage and prompts petition.