Joan Bakewell, the last Labour government's spokesperson for the elderly told ITV News, "I think it's very important to start debate on this."
"However, Paul Burstow has set the bar very low, and I think to suggest that everybody except those who are on pension credits is spreading the net far too wide. A lot of older people need that money."
More top news
Temperatures set to slide
The announcement was hailed as a "momentous step" that will help families facing financial stress as they come to terms with their loss.
Pop Idol's Michelle McManus has joined 10 choirs to record a charity single that they hope will make Christmas Number One.