We obviously back rail investment to improve the service but passengers have already suffered enough pain with a decade of annual inflation-plus fare increases.
They should not now be expected to face another six years of even higher fares. No one expects motorists to pay more for new roads or air passengers to pay for new runways. Well rail passengers should not be singled out to pay for new lines.
They have been persecuted enough already.
More top news
The wrestling hall of fame star 'Rowdy' Roddy Piper has died aged 61.
Labour has called for compensation from the French government to be paid to Britons affected by the chaos at Calais.
Andy Burnham warns far-left supporters of fellow Labour leadership candidate Jeremy Corbyn are putting party at risk of a 1980s-style split.