Ashley Foster, who is from High Green, and Jonathan Bowling, who is from the Fox Hill area of north Sheffield, were both arrested earlier this week.
They will remain in police custody until they appear in court in the morning.
Grandfather Mr Greaves, 68, was a lay preacher and his death shocked the community where he lived.
He lived just a few hundred yards from where he was attacked.
After the incident he was taken to hospital with severe injuries to his head but did not survive.
More than 50 police officers were drafted into the inquiry and detectives made a series of appeals for help from the community.
More top news
More than 40 celebrities have received damages and an apology from Mirror Group Newspapers (MGN) over phone-hacking.
Last month, £55 million was raised by the DEC appeal to raise funds for millions of people facing starvation in East Africa.
The French president has delivered posthumous awards in a national ceremony in Paris as the slain officer's partner appealed for peace.