Imani Green may have been shot dead in revenge for an earlier attack.
The eight-year-old had been visiting relatives in Duncans - a town in northern Jamaica with a relatively low crime-rate - since shortly before the new year.
Police are investigating the theory, along with several other lines of inquiry.
The Foreign Office said it is providing consular assistance to Imani's family, from Balham, south London.
More top news
Gordon Anglesea was found guilty on four counts of indecent assault that took place between 1982 and 1987.
Largely dry and fairly cloudy this afternoon with a few scattered showers and some sunny spells.
European Commission President said an EU-Canada free trade deal would help end Canadian visa restrictions for Romanians and Bulgarians.