Imani Green may have been shot dead in revenge for an earlier attack.
The eight-year-old had been visiting relatives in Duncans - a town in northern Jamaica with a relatively low crime-rate - since shortly before the new year.
Police are investigating the theory, along with several other lines of inquiry.
The Foreign Office said it is providing consular assistance to Imani's family, from Balham, south London.
More top news
The father of Ched Evans' rape victim claims people are trying to track down and kill his daughter over the ordeal.
Tacloban in the Philippines is still trying to pick up the pieces one year on from the devastating Typhoon Haiyan.
A new teacher has been hailed a hero after she intervened when a student opened fire in a school killing a girl and injuring four others.