The Commons Public Administration Committee listed a number of errors in Cabinet Secretary Sir Jeremy Heywood's inquiry into former chief whip Andrew Mitchell's "plebgate" row.
- The committee said it was "surprising" that Sir Jeremy had not been aware of a note of a conversation that the No 10 head of security and the Prime Minister's principal private secretary had with the officer concerned shortly after the incident.
- They said it was "equally surprising" that he did not establish whether a reported leak of the police log was actually true.
- Sir Jeremy should have advised David Cameron to refer the matter to the relevant police authorities so they could resolve any "discrepancies and inconsistencies", they added.
More top news
In the hours following the incident, journalists Can Dundar and Erdem Gul were found guilty in their trial for revealing state secrets.
After a wintry end to last week, a fast track to summer
The government has made its third U-turn in a matter of days as the prime minister struggles to push policy through on a slim majority.