The education select committee report on exam reform states that in 2011/12, 41.4% of pupils did not get five GCSEs, including English and maths, at grades A*-C.
It suggested the government should focus on improving the achievement of the "significant minority" that do not achieve five good GCSEs.
"While it is right to raise young people's expectations and aspirations, we fail to see how raising the bar will automatically result in more young people achieving higher standards," the report said.
"Furthermore, we have serious concerns about how well the proposed reforms will serve the 40% plus of pupils who do not achieve the Government's current floor standard."
More top news
Tonight it'll become dry and clear for most parts of Britain.
More than 30 lions rescued from circuses in South America have arrived in Johannesburg to begin a new life at an African wildlife reserve.
A pensioner who made neighbours' lives a misery, including displaying images of Miss Piggy to torment an overweight woman, has been jailed.