Splitting up offenders between the public and private sector according to risk threatens public protection.
Offenders are generally not a compliant, problem free, group of people. They disproportionately suffer from mental illness, are four times more likely than the general population to misuse drugs and are 10 times more likely to have been in care.
They need to be supervised by experienced staff who can motivate them and properly assess risk.
More top news
Two brothers who rescued a bald eagle from a trap managed to take this selfie with the bird before it flew away.
A woman is being hunted by police after posting a picture of her dog's mouth duct-taped shut because it wouldn't "shut up".
Britain is to be lashed by gales of up to 70mph today as Storm Clodagh makes its arrival from the Atlantic.