Splitting up offenders between the public and private sector according to risk threatens public protection.
Offenders are generally not a compliant, problem free, group of people. They disproportionately suffer from mental illness, are four times more likely than the general population to misuse drugs and are 10 times more likely to have been in care.
They need to be supervised by experienced staff who can motivate them and properly assess risk.
More top news
Regulators and ministers say energy prices are too high and customer service is poor, writes Joel Hills - but one industry boss disagrees.
Pictures posted online appeared to show Flight BEI284 from Edinburgh with a collapsed right landing gear.
Unemployed Daniel Harris was accused of making "vast profits" by sending drug couriers on mopeds disguised as trainee cab drivers.