Splitting up offenders between the public and private sector according to risk threatens public protection.
Offenders are generally not a compliant, problem free, group of people. They disproportionately suffer from mental illness, are four times more likely than the general population to misuse drugs and are 10 times more likely to have been in care.
They need to be supervised by experienced staff who can motivate them and properly assess risk.
More top news
A teenager from Bradford who was indoctrinated with 'chilling' extremist views has been jailed for plotting to go to Syria to fight for IS.
Georgina Ferguson was on a carriage behind the one that was bombed. This is her very personal story of 7/7.
HSBC has sacked employees who staged a mock Islamic State-style beheading during a team-building exercise.