Top of the satisfaction table, compiled from responses from 7,500 regular train users was West Coast main line operator Virgin Trains with a score of 67%.
London Overground was second with 65%, while the London to Tilbury and Southend company c2c and Merseyrail both scored 64%.
Which? who compiled the survey said: "One First Capital Connect customer told us: 'The price has increased and the trains get more and more crowded. I never see any improvements for the extra money I am paying'.
"And a Southeastern passenger said: 'The prices are terrible, the service is bad and trains are often delayed, cancelled and dirty.'."
More top news
Theresa May will tell European counterparts their shared political legacies depend on agreeing a good Brexit deal.
What does Theresa May's request for a couple of years of "transition" to full Brexit mean for Britain the the EU?
Mexico's navy says there are no missing children at a collapsed school where rescuers have been hunting for a trapped girl.