Magistrate Desmond Nair has difficulty appreciating why Reeva wouldn't have screamed back from the toilet.
He says there are improbabilities which need to be explored under oath. Pistorius is furiously sobbing, as the decision is moments away.
More top news
A touch brighter to the southeast but still a great deal of cloud cover across the UK with patchy rain in the west.
A teenager has been expelled from school after posting insults about his headteacher on Facebook.
A former Fox employee has died after apparently shooting himself outside the front doors of the News Corporation building.