Magistrate Desmond Nair has difficulty appreciating why Reeva wouldn't have screamed back from the toilet.
He says there are improbabilities which need to be explored under oath. Pistorius is furiously sobbing, as the decision is moments away.
More top news
MI5 face mounting pressure over claims the IS executioner 'Jihadi John', named yesterday as a London graduate, was known to them
Labour leader Ed Miliband is due to set out his party's plans on how it would cut tuition fees.
New drug driving laws are to come into effect next week, including laws on some prescribed medications.