Magistrate Desmond Nair has difficulty appreciating why Reeva wouldn't have screamed back from the toilet.
He says there are improbabilities which need to be explored under oath. Pistorius is furiously sobbing, as the decision is moments away.
More top news
Flammable cladding has been found on 75 high-rise buildings across 26 local authority areas, MPs have been told.
The decision represents something of a victory for the president who will now be able to enforce most of his controversial 90-day ban.
A contrast in temperature today - with cooler air across the north and warmer air staying further south.