Magistrate Desmond Nair has difficulty appreciating why Reeva wouldn't have screamed back from the toilet.
He says there are improbabilities which need to be explored under oath. Pistorius is furiously sobbing, as the decision is moments away.
More top news
A toddler survived for days on his own after his mother collapsed and died as she fed his one-year-old brother - who also choked to death.
A police officer has won a legion of fans after a picture of him comforting a baby girl caught up in a horror car crash went viral.
A mother has claimed that she was left a spiteful note from fellow diners accusing her son of "ruining" their meal with his screaming.