Lawyers representing Danny Nightingale tried to quash the conviction at another Court of Appeal hearing.
They told three appeal judges that Sgt Nightingale had been placed under "undue pressure" to plead guilty by a barrister who represented him at the military court hearing.
Lawyers argued that the conviction was therefore "unsafe" and Sgt Nightingale's guilty plea a "nullity".
More top news
Is another prediction from the Back To The Future universe about to come true?
To the undoubted tragedy that was the killing of Reeva Steenkamp, the South Africa judicial system has added layers of legal soap opera.
Cathryn Hall is campaigning for police widows' pensions to be payable for life even if they form a new partnership or remarry.