Sustrans Cymru - an organisation that promotes greener transport - has condemned the potential M4 Toll as "poor value for money".
A spokesman said that a "more cost effective way to reduce congestion would be to invest in shifting these journeys to public transport."
"The Welsh Government acknowledges that 40% of journeys on this stretch of the M4 are local trips of under 20 miles," he added.
More top news
A Conservative local election candidate who said she could never support Ed Miliband "the Jew" has been suspended by the party.
Becoming prime minster may be Ed Miliband's principal ambition now, but he has revealed he previously coveted the role of bus conductor.
The Sun's former managing editor has given a tearful account of his three years of "mental torment" after prosecutors dropped all charges.