We have seen with the M6 Toll that drivers can be turned off by the imposition of charges. There is already a toll to get into Wales on the Severn Crossing but no toll to get out.
There is no doubt that the M4 around Newport needs improving. At the moment if there is a bad accident and the road is closed there is no real alternative for drivers.
But if the road is tolled it reduced its economic effectiveness as a lot of people will be put off using it and will simply avoid it.
More top news
Newly crowned double Formula One world champion Lewis Hamilton had a phenomenal season. Here is a look at his career and season in numbers.
Work to recover the wreckage of downed Malaysia Airlines flight MH17 has finally finished.
Five political leaders have agreed to tackle young people's questions in a series of live Q&As on YouTube. Here's how you can get involved…