Around 500,000 low energy users, who tend to be on the lowest incomes, could be advised on the wrong tariffs, under new proposals by Ofgem, Which? said.
Rising energy bills remain one of consumers' top financial concerns yet six in 10 of us have never switched supplier as people are left baffled by the vast array of complicated tariffs.
These current proposals are far too complicated and will fail to achieve their aim of making it easier for people to find the best deal, with three-quarters of people being asked to compare prices that are not based on their energy usage.
More top news
A five-year-old boy whose surprise meeting with "Spiderman" became an online hit has died.
It's going to feel very cold in parts today, with temperatures between 3C and 6C before falling to as low as -6C in some areas overnight.
A son paid off his parents' mortgage for Christmas - reducing them to tears.