Analysis has been prepared by Treasury civil servants and their analysis shows that the current arrangements of a full monetary, fiscal, political union bring economic benefits to all parts of the United Kingdom.
Breaking up that union would represent a fundamental change and confront an independent Scottish state with difficult choices about what to put in its place.
More top news
Find out where the year's political shocks and England's football failure rank, plus the UK's most followed celeb and most talked about TV.
Politician who helped engineer Brexit and was a key supporter to Donald Trump during US election is shortlisted for the prestigious award.
Scientists found the drug - meant to treat cancer patients - rejuvenated eggs to that of pre-pubescent girls.