Ashley Foster has been convicted of the manslaughter of Alan Greaves, but there was confusion in court when the clerk only asked the jury foreman whether he was guilty of murder.
When the foreman said "not guilty" there were celebrations from Foster's family.
But as Mr Greaves's widow Maureen looked shocked and confused, the jury foreman, who had already been asked to sit, shouted "but guilty of manslaughter".
At this point Foster's girlfriend Natalie Evers burst into tears and ran from the court screaming.
More top news
The England cricket captain is the first Englishman and youngest player to ever achieve the landmark.
Police are appealing for news of Connor Jarvis, 19, after he did not return from a solo holiday in Marrakech as planned.
The Leicester City ace said he "felt himself starting to go" when he saw his bride on their magical wedding day last week.