Neighbour of Tia Sharp's grandmother Paul Meehan gave a detailed and "vivid" description of what she was wearing, the court heard, which delayed police from interviewing Stuart Hazell earlier.
But police had spoke to Meehan about the case three times before he finally said he saw her.
His explanation is that he "confabulated" seeing her - his brain mistakenly filled in the blanks in good faith.
More top news
With cloudy skies for most this afternoon, some rain will move southwards through England and Wales.
The jailing of the British sailor - who was caught "red handed" - came as it emerged he is also wanted in connection with a murder in Spain.
A pregnant Brazilian woman who faced deportation is allowed to stay in Britain after a Home Office U-turn over Zika virus fears.