The Department of Transport has defended the fact that English rail passengers will face a sharper rise in average regulated fares than people boarding Scottish trains.
The railways in Scotland are heavily subsidised by the taxpayer. If these levels of subsidy were replicated on railways in England, the cost would be hundreds of pounds a year for every household in England, whether or not they used the train.
More top news
Armed police were out in force as runners competed in the largest public event in the city since Monday's terror attack.
Taliesin Myrddin Namkai Meche, 23, was stabbed along with Rick Best, 53, when they tried to stop a racist attack on two Muslim girls.
The shadow home secretary, 63, said she worked in the Home Office for nearly three years when she was a trainee.