Plans for High Speed 2 took a blow today as they were attacked on both financial and environmental grounds.
A report by the Institute for Economic Affairs suggested that the cost of the project is likely to double official estimates, reaching £80 billion.
The charity Campaign for Rural England also said it believes half a million people - including some living 40 miles from the planned route - would be affected by the construction.
But the chief executive of HS2, Alison Munro, described the claimw as "absurd" and insisted the project would remain within budget.
ITV News correspondent Lewis Vaughan Jones reports:
More top news
Cloud and showery rain may linger across the far northwest throughout Saturday.
For the NHS to remain at the centre of our lives, it will have to change how it treats us or we will have to change how we treat it.
Pro-gun protesters met Barack Obama in Oregon as he arrived to console victims and affected families of the community college shooting.