Juliet Lyon, director of the Prison Reform Trust, has said closing small local prisons and replacing them with super-sized prisons "will not reduce crime or make communities safer".
She added: "The millions secured for new-build prisons could be more effectively spent on robust community service, treatment for addicts and care for people who are mentally ill."
She added: "Smaller prisons tend to be safer and more effective than larger establishments, holding people closer to home and with a higher ratio of prison staff to prisoners.
"Prison ought to be an important place of last resort in our justice system, not a giant economic regeneration or job creation scheme."
More top news
Louis Walsh reignites the flames of his row with by claiming she would refuse to be an X Factor judge if Nicole Scherzinger returns.
Ex Army chief calls on Government to "think the previously unthinkable" and consider sending ground troops to combat Islamic State.
Rio Ferdinand has described being "overwhelmed" by the support he received from football fans after his wife died.