The Sunderland chaplain who presented a red and white striped shirt to Pope Francis said the pontiff was "delighted to keep it" and took the gift back to the papal apartments.
Father Marc Lyden-Smith said the Pope was aware of the Wearside club's struggles and told him: "They not do too well at the moment."
"I said no, no, Holy Father. They are bottom of the Premier League. We need you to pray."
"Very diplomatically, he said: 'I pray for all footballers that they reach their potential.'"
"I'd like to think that he'll be wearing [the Sunderland shirt] on Sunday afternoon," the chaplain added.
Winless Sunderland face fierce local rivals Newcastle United in Wear-Tyne derby this Sunday.
More top news
Ex Army chief calls on Government to "think the previously unthinkable" and consider sending ground troops to combat Islamic State.
Rio Ferdinand has described being "overwhelmed" by the support he received from football fans after his wife died.
The world's oldest-known person, Jeralean Talley, celebrated her 116th birthday with family and friends at a restaurant in Michigan.