The managing director of Newtork Rail's network operations told the Today programme that any attempt to upgrade existing lines, rather than implement the HS2, would inevitably lead to "very heavy disruption" to services.
Spending £20 billion on upgrading the existing network isn't an alternative. The disruption that would be caused would be a nightmare. This report makes that absolutely clear.
It would only give us a third of the additional capacity which would mean that we would not be able to put more freight on the rail, we would not be able to put additional services into intermediate stations.
More top news
Dean Lucas and Adam Coleman were in Mexico on a surf trip but it is feared they may have been victims of local violence.
Favourite Jessica Ennis-Hill is joined by last minute additions Tyson Fury and Andy Murray on the list of Sports Personality nominees.
Jenny Fry, 15, claimed she had electro-hypersensitivity (EHS) which caused her to suffer tiredness, headaches and bladder problems.