David McCorquodale, head of retail at accountants KPMG, who sponsored today's retail sales survey by the British Retail Consortium said the poor figures show Britain's economic recovery is a "slow, relentless slog".
October was another difficult month for retailers, reminding us that recovery is a slow, relentless slog.
Whilst the summer months hinted at increased consumer confidence, retailers will struggle to maintain a sustained sales recovery until wage growth outpaces price inflation.
More top news
A fine evening ahead to the south with some late sunshine in places.
Prince Charles and the Duchess of Cornwall have visited Manchester Arena, the site of a suicide bombing in May which left 22 people dead.
Flammable cladding has been found on 75 high-rise buildings across 26 local authority areas, MPs have been told.