David McCorquodale, head of retail at accountants KPMG, who sponsored today's retail sales survey by the British Retail Consortium said the poor figures show Britain's economic recovery is a "slow, relentless slog".
October was another difficult month for retailers, reminding us that recovery is a slow, relentless slog.
Whilst the summer months hinted at increased consumer confidence, retailers will struggle to maintain a sustained sales recovery until wage growth outpaces price inflation.
More top news
Four people are presumed dead after heavy rainstorms triggered flooding in south-west Germany.
A man has been arrested over an offensive Hillsborough shirt
Early low cloud will gradually retreat to North Sea coasts to leave many with a fine day, particularly in the west.