The Government has rejected an offer from security firm G4S to repay the £24m it owes for overcharging in credit notes.
Officials turned down the settlement and say they will "pursue all possible avenues" to recoup more taxpayers' money.
A Ministry of Justice spokesman said it was still working with the firms and the independent auditors to work out "what the final sum will be".
"The Secretary of State has been clear: we are determined to secure a refund for the taxpayer.
"We have taken appropriate legal advice and will pursue all possible avenues."
More top news
Tonight turning foggy in places but frost free
Governor says Article 50 fears not Bank actions to blame for pound's plunge, but admits markets may yet have "mistaken" Brexit impact.
Conservative MP Zac Goldsmith read out a statement on his decision to force a by-election in protest at new runway at Heathrow Airport.