The triple murderer awarded £815 because his nose hair clippers were broken by a prison guard "should not be paid anything", a Conservative MP told Good Morning Britain.
Nadine Dorries dubbed Kevan Thakrar's claim "quite bizarre" and "difficult to either believe or understand".
"If you or I lose our personal possession we don't have a claim for £800 to repay us. And most of this payment was made because a prison officer failed to apologise because he was stressed over losing his belongings."
More top news
Diane Abbott dismissed the idea of the Labour leader standing down even if the party loses both seats in the upcoming by-elections.
Levels of safety are not high enough in prisons, meaning that reform of inmates cannot take place, Prisons Minister Sam Gyimah has said.
The Government's Prevent campaign is "simply not trusted" by many British Muslims, the Independent Reviewer of Terrorism Legislation said.