Judges at the Court of Appeal have upheld a sentence given to Lewis Gill, who was found guilty of manslaughter after punching Andrew Young, 40, in an unprovoked attack.
Mr Young later died from a head injury which he suffered when he hit the ground.
Mr Gill, 20, was sentenced to four years in jail for the offence, a decision which provoked outrage.
The incident occurred on November 6 last year outside the Tesco Metro store on Charminster Road in Bournemouth.
Gill later pleaded guilty to manslaughter and was sentenced at Salisbury Crown Court.
Attorney General Dominic Grieve argued today that the sentence was not a proper reflection of the gravity of what Gill did.
But the Appeal Court judges decided there should not be any change to the four years being served by Mr Gill.
More top news
The pensioner, who is in her 70s, says her daughter has suffered from Huntington's disease.
US singer John Legend said he was "moved" by footage of the teenager singing one of his songs.
John Noakes was Blue Peter's longest-serving presenter.